Showcase - February 21-27, 2022
- Thread starter Fade
- Start date
-
Beat This!The Beat This! results are in, see what went down.
- Status
hosie
ILLIEN
Battle Points: 5
*resists the urge to play Dilla beat first*
Okay, So I've listened to both beats before leaving feedback...
Fonky Abduction - Doesn't quite hit the mark for me this one - probably because (spoiler alert!) the Dilla beat just blew my socks off. There's an off-beat snare that comes in too early and nowhere near anything else musically. The piano doesn't quite flow naturally either. There's just a bit in the middle where it upsets the rhythmic sound of the beat. The sample and drums in general I can't fault and with a bit of tinkering will give you a really nice boom bap beat!
Donut's in the Wind - Now, this is beautiful. Sample is perfect. Really nice. The drums come in and I'm like "Damn, I'd have like them to be a little lou- oh here they are!!" Nice filtering with the drums at the start, it actually works really well. The drums are perfect too. Really, so so good. I love this beat! Great work as always mate.
Here's another remix I just finished last night. Still rough around the edges as always but you get the vibe! feedback appreciated as always. Looking forward to hearing another @MR. MINESTATE remix from 2004
Okay, So I've listened to both beats before leaving feedback...
Fonky Abduction - Doesn't quite hit the mark for me this one - probably because (spoiler alert!) the Dilla beat just blew my socks off. There's an off-beat snare that comes in too early and nowhere near anything else musically. The piano doesn't quite flow naturally either. There's just a bit in the middle where it upsets the rhythmic sound of the beat. The sample and drums in general I can't fault and with a bit of tinkering will give you a really nice boom bap beat!
Donut's in the Wind - Now, this is beautiful. Sample is perfect. Really nice. The drums come in and I'm like "Damn, I'd have like them to be a little lou- oh here they are!!" Nice filtering with the drums at the start, it actually works really well. The drums are perfect too. Really, so so good. I love this beat! Great work as always mate.
Here's another remix I just finished last night. Still rough around the edges as always but you get the vibe! feedback appreciated as always. Looking forward to hearing another @MR. MINESTATE remix from 2004
nikwen
ILLIEN
The piano + guitar combo is groovy. Love the overall vibe. I wonder if it would sound a bit better if those two instruments were a bit less loud compared to the rest of the track though? (Maybe that's skewed by the cheap laptop speakers I was listening through though?)
Drums solid. Nothing to comment there.
nikwen
ILLIEN
The sax sounds great! Got this old-school feeling.
Overall, I would have loved more variation. The beat itself is good but I got bored after 1-2 minutes of freestyling because it didn't change in a significant way.
Rah.sool
Beatmaker
@hosie Thanks for the feedback brother! Yea man this was kind of experimental haha. I played most of the piano and the sample was used sparingly. Definitely have some work to do on this style.
The Good People: Very nice job man. I really like the chops, drums and the overall mix. The only feedback I have is that it sounds like you put a highpass on the vocal, I would prefer a tad more bass on the vocals personally. But you may have made that decision based on how it was sitting over the chops. something to think about. Awesome job man!
@nikwen thanks for the feedback bud
The Good People: Very nice job man. I really like the chops, drums and the overall mix. The only feedback I have is that it sounds like you put a highpass on the vocal, I would prefer a tad more bass on the vocals personally. But you may have made that decision based on how it was sitting over the chops. something to think about. Awesome job man!
@nikwen thanks for the feedback bud
MR. MINESTATE
Newbie
Electronic- This is definitely different from the last joint I heard, but keeps that sound boom bap format. Smooth vibe. I like the warm bassline. The drum pattern is different than the "boom boom click" we hear in a lot of boom bap beats. Dope! The keys are on point. Love the "electronic" sounds.
J-dilla Style- Drums on point. Bass line- nice and warm like fresh oatmeal. I love the way the filter comes in around the verse part. Very Jazzy feel.
MR. MINESTATE
Newbie
*resists the urge to play Dilla beat first*
Okay, So I've listened to both beats before leaving feedback...
Fonky Abduction - Doesn't quite hit the mark for me this one - probably because (spoiler alert!) the Dilla beat just blew my socks off. There's an off-beat snare that comes in too early and nowhere near anything else musically. The piano doesn't quite flow naturally either. There's just a bit in the middle where it upsets the rhythmic sound of the beat. The sample and drums in general I can't fault and with a bit of tinkering will give you a really nice boom bap beat!
Donut's in the Wind - Now, this is beautiful. Sample is perfect. Really nice. The drums come in and I'm like "Damn, I'd have like them to be a little lou- oh here they are!!" Nice filtering with the drums at the start, it actually works really well. The drums are perfect too. Really, so so good. I love this beat! Great work as always mate.
Here's another remix I just finished last night. Still rough around the edges as always but you get the vibe! feedback appreciated as always. Looking forward to hearing another @MR. MINESTATE remix from 2004
*resists the urge to play Dilla beat first*
Okay, So I've listened to both beats before leaving feedback...
Fonky Abduction - Doesn't quite hit the mark for me this one - probably because (spoiler alert!) the Dilla beat just blew my socks off. There's an off-beat snare that comes in too early and nowhere near anything else musically. The piano doesn't quite flow naturally either. There's just a bit in the middle where it upsets the rhythmic sound of the beat. The sample and drums in general I can't fault and with a bit of tinkering will give you a really nice boom bap beat!
Donut's in the Wind - Now, this is beautiful. Sample is perfect. Really nice. The drums come in and I'm like "Damn, I'd have like them to be a little lou- oh here they are!!" Nice filtering with the drums at the start, it actually works really well. The drums are perfect too. Really, so so good. I love this beat! Great work as always mate.
Here's another remix I just finished last night. Still rough around the edges as always but you get the vibe! feedback appreciated as always. Looking forward to hearing another @MR. MINESTATE remix from 2004
*resists the urge to play Dilla beat first*
Okay, So I've listened to both beats before leaving feedback...
Fonky Abduction - Doesn't quite hit the mark for me this one - probably because (spoiler alert!) the Dilla beat just blew my socks off. There's an off-beat snare that comes in too early and nowhere near anything else musically. The piano doesn't quite flow naturally either. There's just a bit in the middle where it upsets the rhythmic sound of the beat. The sample and drums in general I can't fault and with a bit of tinkering will give you a really nice boom bap beat!
Donut's in the Wind - Now, this is beautiful. Sample is perfect. Really nice. The drums come in and I'm like "Damn, I'd have like them to be a little lou- oh here they are!!" Nice filtering with the drums at the start, it actually works really well. The drums are perfect too. Really, so so good. I love this beat! Great work as always mate.
Here's another remix I just finished last night. Still rough around the edges as always but you get the vibe! feedback appreciated as always. Looking forward to hearing another @MR. MINESTATE remix from 2004
@hosie I had to listen to the original before I checked out the remixed version. I likes. It keeps the same spirit of the original. The vocals are aligned right. The drums are dope. Reminds me of joints I would listen to when the famous Stretch Armstrong and Bobbito show used to come on. The only thing I would say it could use a pocket during the hook part of the song. Other than that, dope. That real hip hop vibe.
hosie
ILLIEN
Battle Points: 5
Thanks Rah! Appreciate the feedback. You're bang on with the high-pass. It's something I often find myself doing. It's sort of become a signature thing as I have my presets set for most of my tracks now.
@MR. MINESTATE Thanks man! Appreciate the feedback as always. Interesting you mentioned about the pocket as I actually did that a few times but resorted back to the guitar part as I felt it drooped the rhythm / tempo too much. Might try and look at it again. Cheers!
hosie
ILLIEN
Battle Points: 5
Thanks @nikwen . Sorry I missed this feedback from the other day. Really appreciate the constructive feedback. I think you could be right about lowering them ever so slghtly but yea I doubt the laptop speakers help. I tend to listen to all of beats on headphones, then phone up loud and then in car. Try to get the best mix from that and it's usually decent. Cheers!
hosie
ILLIEN
Battle Points: 5
I normally try to avoid putting up more than 1 beat in a week but I'd really appreciate your thoughts on this one.
I know the intro is a tad long but there was a spoken word part here which I have removed as it is too recognisable. I plan to replace with a more original or lesser known segment. I am looking at this potentially being an intro on my EP, so any feedback / thoughts are appreciated.
Thanks
Hosie
Nothing here yet.
I know the intro is a tad long but there was a spoken word part here which I have removed as it is too recognisable. I plan to replace with a more original or lesser known segment. I am looking at this potentially being an intro on my EP, so any feedback / thoughts are appreciated.
Thanks
Hosie
MR. MINESTATE
Newbie
Keep up the good work bro!
MR. MINESTATE
Newbie
@hosie I rapped before I started making beats. I have more beats than anything else though. This is the type of beat I could write some bars to. Politically conscious type raps.
MR. MINESTATE
Newbie
This track I did 9 years ago. My favorite oldie to me...new to you.
Kane the MOD
Grey haired Boom Bap Rap Dad
Battle Points: 5
Both beats have very nice melodies that work really well together.
I really like the bassline on the J-Dilla type beat.
Very good stuff.
Kane the MOD
Grey haired Boom Bap Rap Dad
Battle Points: 5
*resists the urge to play Dilla beat first*
Okay, So I've listened to both beats before leaving feedback...
Fonky Abduction - Doesn't quite hit the mark for me this one - probably because (spoiler alert!) the Dilla beat just blew my socks off. There's an off-beat snare that comes in too early and nowhere near anything else musically. The piano doesn't quite flow naturally either. There's just a bit in the middle where it upsets the rhythmic sound of the beat. The sample and drums in general I can't fault and with a bit of tinkering will give you a really nice boom bap beat!
Donut's in the Wind - Now, this is beautiful. Sample is perfect. Really nice. The drums come in and I'm like "Damn, I'd have like them to be a little lou- oh here they are!!" Nice filtering with the drums at the start, it actually works really well. The drums are perfect too. Really, so so good. I love this beat! Great work as always mate.
Here's another remix I just finished last night. Still rough around the edges as always but you get the vibe! feedback appreciated as always. Looking forward to hearing another @MR. MINESTATE remix from 2004
Great vibe. Came out really dope.
Kane the MOD
Grey haired Boom Bap Rap Dad
Battle Points: 5
I think the intro is dope and I like how you flipped the sample. Only thing I would work on is the ending of the beat.
There is something about the snare... I don't know what it is (probably just me). Did you try to pitch it down 1-2 semitone and compare it to the original?
Keep up the good work.
OGBama
Big Clit Energy
If @MR. MINESTATE you rapped before producing please continue as Hip Hop needs more adults rapping. Not that there aren't any but Hip Hop has an aversion to maturity.
MR. MINESTATE
Newbie
OGBama
Big Clit Energy
The @MR. MINESTATE part of me that likes/loves Hip Hop isn’t afraid to critique it.
- Status
