If we are a site of professional beat makers then we should act like professionals. If we are judging a beat and it isn't mixed properly and the other is but both are still kinda whack then vote for the beat that was mixed the best. If both beats are not mixed and are whack then vote for the best "sounding" beat. When the results are tallied and we see who made what lets all try to give constructive criticism. Its up to the advanced producers here to help the next person up, regardless if they won or not. If you lost and someone tells you about your beat take the criticism like a man and take it for what its worth. No one here is SwissBeatz or Dr. Dre but i can assure you that from this point on I will be giving my opinion on beats that i think i should and I hope the same is done for me in the process. I mean we already have a section where we can get feedback but its not competitive so i think no-one takes it as serious.