Yeah, I think you may have to re-approach it by choosing one of those elements to focus on. Find whichever is your key element, highlight it. Then use the other elements sparingly or more subtly bringing in. Also it may open room to use more of them at once in the vein you have later as like a bridge, or little post-chorus type sections.
If you're happy with what you're going for, may have to use those mixing abilities of yours to drift things in and out in a less conflicting way and could actually be quite surreal/ interesting.